A New Tragedy in Ulster

We are accustomed to horror stories from Northern Ireland, although thankfully they have been a bit less frequent of late.  But now we read of a new one.  Catriona Ruane, the ideologue Sinn Fein Education Minister of Northern Ireland has scrapped the eleven plus exam in the province, on the grounds that it is “an outdated and unequal education system”.  She is wrong.  On the contrary, it is the comprehensive system which has comprehensively failed our children and our economy.  It has been tested to destruction and found wanting.  (Oddly enough, no one seems to have decided what system to put in its place).
 
The facts are so well known that it is almost unnecessary to rehearse them.  Northern Ireland is a “test market” for the selective system, providing a head-to-head comparison with large parts of England, and it demonstrates convincingly that the selective system delivers better results.  And not just for those who “pass” the 11+, but for all children in the province, whichever type of school they go to.  Now that the selective system has been proven to be the better system, Ms. Ruane wants to abandon it.
 
We made a terrible presentational error in allowing ourselves to speak of “passing” and “failing” the 11+.  What we were doing was making sure that every child was offered to best education for their talents, whether academic or vocational.  Children — all children, not just academic children — do best when offered courses that engage their interest and match their capabilities.  It is in this critical area that comprehensives so patently fail.  And their failure is compounded by a Labour government determined to send too many children on to academic tertiary education to which the majority are clearly unsuited.
 
That is why we are slipping down the international league tables for educational attainment.  That is why our economic future is under threat, as we fail to deliver qualified applicants for the jobs — whether academic of vocational — that a modern economy demands.
 
We could be forgiven (just about) for the errors of the sixties.  But with nearly half a century of experience under our belts, we cannot be forgiven for making the same mistakes again.  All together now: “Competition is inevitable, and élitism is good”.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to A New Tragedy in Ulster

  1. Backbench Warrior says:

    So a politician who takes the whip and represents a Party which has turned its back on selective education, condeamns a politician from another Party who has turned their back on selective education.

    No matter we are in such a sorry state.

  2. Roger Helmer says:

    We should surely be in a sorrier state if every politician in a major party parroted the Party Line, and if none of them ever took an independent position.

  3. Backbench Warrior says:

    Only if an independent position is taken on occasions when they would actually mean something; i.e. if you had told Conservative HQ to stick it when they slapped you on the wrist for DARING to agree to debate Nigel Farage on the your Party’s ‘policy’ on the EU at a Bruges Group meeting.

    Here, on the safe confines of your blog, an ‘independent position’ means next to nothing.

  4. paceni says:

    Don’t worry, says David Cameron, Carol Vorderman will sort out numeracy for the Conservative Party. It seems she as she not heard of England’s position on the latest TIMMS mathematics survey citing instead the useless PISA listing.
    Cameron’s education policy is hopeless.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s