On Caravans, I agree with Clarkson

I have to admit that I tend to agree with Jeremy Clarkson on caravans.  OK.  Hands up.  I confess.  I agree with Jeremy Clarkson on practically everything, but especially caravans.

Partly this is sheer selfishness, born of the rage and frustration engendered by sitting for half-an-hour behind a convoy of cars and a caravan, at thirty-five miles an hour, while I drive around the East Midlands region on single-carriageway roads with no realistic overtaking opportunities.  But the frustration takes on added piquancy when I reflect on the sheer pointlessness of it all.

First of all, caravans are not cheap.  You pay to buy one, then you pay the interest on the loan (or suffer the opportunity cost of not doing something better with your money, like putting it in your pension fund).  Then you pay to store the caravan, in money if you’re on someone else’s site, or in visual amenity (to both you and your neighbours) if it’s on your front drive.  You pay to insure it and maintain it and to equip it, and for all I know you pay to tax it and MOT it too.

Then you tow it.  Even if you can ignore the rage of the drivers behind you, you are still stuck with a long, low-speed, tedious journey.  There’s more wear-and-tear on your car with a van, and of course your fuel consumption rockets when towing.

Arriving at your chosen camp-site, you pay again for the privilege of parking up in the corner of a damp field, and perhaps extra for connecting water and electricity.  And after all that, you still have to do your own cooking and washing up and general house work.  Not much of a holiday.

Why on earth don’t they just book into a nice rural B&B?  They’d have just as much flexibility, a great journey down, a comfortable bed, a hot farmhouse breakfast – and no chores!  They’d have rather more protection from the weather.  And someone else would make the bed!  I suspect that unless you use the caravan constantly, the B&B option would be no more expensive, and perhaps cheaper.

So what are the arguments in favour?  I remember a former colleague long ago in Colchester telling me that he and his wife loved to take the caravan to France, because they could stock it with so much tinned Spam and baked beans that they could avoid all that funny French food.  But for me, funny French food is one of the main attractions, so I’m afraid his comment simply confirmed my worst suspicions about caravanners.

But I guess there’s one unanswerable benefit of owning a caravan.  When Mother-in-Law comes to stay, you can put her in her own self-contained apartment on the front drive, where she can do her own washing up and stay out of your hair.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to On Caravans, I agree with Clarkson

  1. Sean O'Hare says:

    I have a motorhome rather than a caravan and have been nicked for speeding in it, so I’m not guilty on the causing tailbacks accusation.

    I do think you are being more than a little uncharitable on the pleasures of caravanning though. Staying in B&B’s is far less comfortable. Most B&Bs don’t provide a lounge to sit around in and no B&B landlady wants their guests hanging around or frequently coming and going.

    You have obviously stayed in a much better class of B&B than I, as I can’t say that any I have stayed in (outside Ireland) have produced as good a grilled breakfast as my wife does. I do the washing up which takes a few minutes and is not a holiday spoiler.

    Caravan sites are much more relaxed than B&Bs and there is a sociable club atmosphere which you can either take or leave. Even in the UK the sites aren’t all damp fields all of the time and this year we have enjoyed around 25 days of glorious camping weather at about one third of the price of a B&B. Of course that does exclude depreciation on the van, but what does that matter if you enjoy it?

    • Thanks for your alternative view. It’s been pointed out to me that with two or three children, a caravan might be cheaper. But I remember a holiday when my two children were small, in a Thames river cruiser (a bit like a caravan), when the weather was so awful we gave up, and made a late booking in a Cornish holiday flat instead!

  2. Kat says:

    I must admit I enjoyed the freedom to come and go but for the cost of owning one ( since I sold it) I have stayed at some very fancy hotels instead, I didn’t use it enough to warrant the cost,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s