Pity the poor posh boy

Benedict Cumberpatch: pity the poor posh boy

There have been some snivelling and querulous complaints in the media recently about the preponderance of posh boys (and girls) in the performing arts.  The resentment of the odious levellers cannot stomach the prominence of public school pupils.  Benedict Cumberpatch has been particularly in the frame, and has spoken of moving to the States, where class prejudice is less of a factor.    Just to lighten up this piece, I tried to find an image of Benedict with an attractive co-star, but oddly, Google Images did not oblige.

But it is absurd to think that hard-headed casting directors are selecting film and TV stars on the basis of their school, university and regiment, as bankers supposedly did in the Swinging Sixties.  There is far too much hanging on the decision — careers, reputations, and a great deal of money.  No.  They choose the candidate they believe will appeal to the public and deliver the ratings.

If that means that a disproportionate number of privately educated candidates are getting the parts, we should be asking how we improve state schools to deliver the same qualities and benefits — not carping at posh boys (and girls) in the media.

Similar comments apply in sport — but more so.  We’ve heard complaints that too many of our Olympic athletes came from a public school background.  Here the case is even more clear-cut than the casting question.  Athletes are selected on plain, objective criteria — they get to the Olympics because they run faster, jump higher, throw farther than their peers.  Again, if we find that there’s a preponderance of public school alumni, we should ask where state schools are failing.  Is it the time available for sports, the facilities, the teaching, the resistance to competition and élitism, the “all must have prizes” culture?

We in Britain need to spend less time attacking excellence, and more time striving to achieve it.

But of course it may be that different rules apply in the field of politics.  It certainly seems that the air of entitlement and easy self-confidence imparted by public school, the natural facade of leadership, may help the public school boy to achieve eminence.  But also — whisper it quietly, especially in Downing Street — could it be that this very self-confidence makes it more difficult for people like Cameron and Osborne, catapulted to the highest levels of government  early in their careers, to see where they’re going wrong — or even to conceive of the idea that they might go wrong?

Certainly our Prime Minister and Chancellor seem rather to vindicate that idea.

(For the avoidance of doubt: I went to a Grammar School).

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Pity the poor posh boy

  1. Rich Tee says:

    Acting is an insecure and mostly poorly paid profession – most actors never get rich and famous. People from well off backgrounds may be an advantage because their parents effectively subsidise their living expenses while they are learning their trade. Same with film directors who are commonly from public schools as well.

    I agree that people whose life was a challenge when they were young actually could be at an advantage later on in life. They are used to working hard, coping with disappointment, looking for opportunities and making the best of them. They are not complacent.

  2. Roger, I once helped to start a successful dotcom business back at the turn of the century. The founders were McKinsey consultants, a hothouse for these so-called posh boys, where I met them while working on an oil and gas project.

    I later recruited a programming team led by an excellent chap who had a PhD in Artificial Intelligence. Top man who became a great friend.

    He himself had been through Winchester College and I once remarked “what is it about these public school , McKinsey types?” He was quite clear in his reply – he told me “We are never in our lives given the slightest opportunity to f**k things up which leads us to thing that such a thing is just not possible” I believe he has a point.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s