Close Bros — Not close enough

This morning on the BBC Today Programme, I heard Nancy Curtin,  Chief Investment Officer of Close Brothers Asset Management talking about the EU.  I was astonished by her ignorance and prejudice.

First of all, she casually observed that “50% of British exports go to the EU”.  Wrong, lady.  It’s about 46%, and that includes goods sent to ports like Rotterdam for re-export out of the EU (the “Rotterdam effect”).  The true figure is certainly closer to 40% than 50%.

And it’s falling.  The EU is in long-term relative decline.  The growth is in the rest of the world.  And that’s true of EU GDP, of the EU share of world trade, and of British exports to the EU.

In any case, the fact that 40%+ of British exports go to an area amounting to around 20% of global GDP is nothing to be proud of.  It’s simply a distortion in our trade patterns, largely caused by our excessive focus on the EU when we have been, and must be, a great global trading nation.  Given that a disproportionate share of our exports depends on the one economic area in the world in long-term relative decline, we should be worried, and we should urgently re-focus our exports to the rest of the world.

Then, with marvellous insouciance, Nancy casually observes that outside the EU, Britain would be “isolated”.  Hang on Nancy.  There are 150 countries in the world (give or take) that are outside the EU.  Are they all “isolated”?  Are the USA, and Canada, and China, and Korea, and Taiwan, and Japan, and Singapore, “isolated” because they’re not members of the EU?  You only need to ask the question to see the absurdity of her position.  When we leave the EU, we shall undoubtedly have a free trade deal with the EU.  Our EU trade will not suffer, but our trade with the rest of the world will have an opportunity to thrive.

And as I so often say, the UK is a key player on the UN Security Council, the G8, the G20, the World Bank, the OECD, NATO, the Commonwealth, and a multitude of other international organisations.  When we leave the EU, we can be represented again in the WTO, where our voice is currently strained through the smothering blanket of Brussels.

I’m rather horrified that a lady in this senior position, serving as a pundit on the Today Programme, can be so ignorant and biased, repeating pro-EU propaganda without, apparently, any serious thought.  I’m glad she’s not investing any funds for me.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Close Bros — Not close enough

  1. “BBC Today Programme, I heard Nancy Curtin, Chief Investment Officer of Close Brothers Asset Management talking about the EU.”
    Well there you go. BBC, Europe, just the place for a balanced unbiased view of reality?

  2. machokong says:

    Let me see, an over-promoted women, with a signature “I’m one of them” bouffant hairdo, in the asset stripping business, talking out her backside with phoney statistics that even the LibDems gave up long ago, a non-elected individual and all on the BBC, well, it’s just the kind of thing that will come back to haunt them.

    I always say: you’ll not get away with this.

  3. JR says:

    The BBC is a waste of rations and should be disbanded. I can then save paying the wastrels MY hard earned cash for their drivel.

  4. And you thought the Today programme was unbiased?
    Shame on you.
    James Mc Naughty is a real left winger and the child of a Scottish Quaker (Spectator last month).

    What is all this about a child being taken away from adoptive parents who are UKIP? My wife read it in the Mail.

  5. I am always quick to disagree with you Roger so thought I should be equally quick to agree with you which having read your post then I absolutely agree, Nancy is pro european and unfortunately a part of a die hard band of delusionals who will never cease to advocate the virtues of the UK being in the E.U totally ignoring the facts or presenting a true & honest case, Leaving the E.U will not damage UK exports and in truth as you say should be a part of our mid/long term plan for easing the decline in EU exports from the UK, we have the whole world to trade with and once loose of the EU shackles then we can trade freely & profitably, The only way we will remove ourselves from this economic position is to freely trade with the whole world where we can and without the restrictions that being in the EU place upon us.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s