The Energy Muddle. And the €uro Elections.


I recently heard that a senior spokesman for the UK energy industry had suggested that the success of “smaller parties” in the forthcoming Euro elections could be problematic for the energy industry. I took this as a veiled reference to UKIP. The quote, as I’ve been given it, reads: “An outcome which would undoubtedly be difficult would be if the European Parliament becomes composed of a large number of smaller parties, because when that happens, coherency is not as good. Although energy is a competency which still sits with separate countries, there is a chunk that is decided on a pan-European basis which we could see get in quite a muddle.”

Asked to comment, I had several observations (no surprise there!). First, what’s a “smaller party”? With hard work and a fair wind, UKIP may well win the largest share of the UK vote, and be the largest UK delegation. Not a “smaller party” at all in Brussels terms.

Secondly, the way the EP operates drives us all into groups, whether we like it or not. So we will still have groups, which should help to avoid the “muddle”, and deliver a degree of coherence.

Third, the overall effect of the election will be that we have many more Eurosceptic MEPs – perhaps 20 to 25% instead of the current (roughly) 10%. And often euro-sceptics turn out to be climate sceptics as well. They are disinclined to accept received wisdom without question. On energy issues, they may well find themselves voting broadly together, even if not formally in the same group.

Fourth, any increase in climate sceptics is likely to support the Commission in its tentative steps back from climate extremism to something more akin to common sense. For too many years they’ve talked about three priorities, competitiveness, security of supply, and “sustainability” (though renewables are not sustainable). But in reality the policy has been geared entirely to (what they call) sustainability – in other words, climate alarmism and green hysteria – and they’ve ignored competitiveness and security of supply. The anticipated changes in the parliament will simply reinforce the new direction of travel towards a more balanced approach, with more emphasis on security of supply and affordability. Indeed one of the silver linings from the Ukraine crisis is a new urgency in the hunt for indigenous energy resources, and especially shale gas, in Europe.

So – if energy companies are interested in being rent-seekers and subsidy junkies, suckling on the teat of the tax-payer, they won’t like the outcome. But if they’re interested in running a successful business ensuring a supply of secure and affordable energy, things are looking up.

Until the question arose, I hadn’t thought of this point. But the probable outcome of the May election – across Europe, not just in the UK – will not be limited simply to gains for freedom and democracy. There could well be big benefits for energy policy too. Roll on May 22nd.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to The Energy Muddle. And the €uro Elections.

  1. Ex-expat Colin says:

    I just wonder what in terms of help this is (WUWT)
    Sigmar Gabriel, acting vice-chancellor of the German government, Secretary of Commerce with responsibility for Energiewende and chairman of the German social democrats (SPD), the second-largest political force in the country.
    “The truth is that the Energy U-Turn (“Energiewende”, the German scheme aimed at pushing the “renewable” share of electricity production to 80 % by 2050) is about to fail”
    “The truth is that under all aspects, we have underestimated the complexity of the “Energiewende”
    “The noble aspiration of a decentralized energy supply, of self-sufficiency! This is of course utter madness”
    “Anyway, most other countries in Europe think we are crazy”

    That was apparently at:
    April 16th, 2014 – a discussion event at the premises of SMA Solar Technology AG, a leading German producer of photovoltaic panels and systems:

    • omanuel says:

      Today I am in awe of:

      1. The courage of a 28-year-old nuclear geochemist in saving the world from totalitarian rule by:

      _ a.) Taking possession of Japan’s atomic bomb plans in 1945:

      _ b.) Designing a research topic in 1960 that would reveal information world leaders had tried to hide from the public in 1945:

      “A Journey to the Core of the Sun – Chapter 2: Acceptance of Reality

      Click to access Chapter_2.pdf

      2. The Divine sense of humor in revealing the Sun’s pulsar core to modern world leaders who thought they could control Earth’s climate!

  2. Graham says:

    It appears, in the UK at least, energy companies could expect quite a different landscape within the next year of two whether Tories or UKIP are the major influence. Mr Cameron’s shift against onshore wind turbines…. oh, wait… that’s a Cameron pre-election commitment. Sorry, as you were, it won’t happen.

    • Adrian Hey says:

      Indeed, and not even any suggestion of an end the even worse (from an economic perspective) offshore wind and STOR schemes. I’ll believe the Tories might be getting serious about energy policy when I see a commitment to repeal the climate change act in their manifesto.

  3. frostyface says:

    I regret that I have to agree with the last two and a half lines of Grahams entry, it just won’t happen. So, I just hope that the gullible public eligible to vote will realise that!

  4. Maureen Gannon says:

    They really do not like democracy do they , they can’t allow us little people to think for ourselves and vote for the good and not the greedy ,
    Germany is pushing all this they are the the biggest manufacturer of the turbines..

  5. kevin says:

    recommended reading:
    Life After Growth: How the global economy really works by Tim Morgan

  6. Pingback: UKIP’s BAPF Newark candidate claims mass destruction of Britain’s countryside is common sense

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s