Letter to the Commissioner


Elzbieta Bienkowska

Dear Commissioner,

I have just read your letter to ITRE Chairman Jerzy Buzek MEP on the subject of the EU’s industrial competitiveness, and I am sorry to say that it left me profoundly depressed – though not quite so depressed as I daresay the Chief Executives of companies across my East Midlands region would feel, had they been obliged to read your pages of bureaucratic verbiage with little substantive content.

It seems to me that there are two major issues.  You mention both, at various points, but you present no significant ideas for serious change.

The first is energy.  As former Industry Commissioner Antonio Tajani put it, “We are creating an Industrial Massacre in Europe (with energy prices)”.  Plants are closing, jobs are lost, investment is being forced out of Europe in a range of energy-intensive businesses, including steel, aluminium, glass, cement, chemicals and petroleum refining.  The extent of plant closures and job losses is alarming, and the effect on imports and balance of payments is dire.

This is happening because of our obsessive commitment to unreliable and intermittent renewable technologies, and our failure to rely on proven low-cost technologies like gas.  I see nothing in your letter that addresses this issue.

Then there is the issue of deregulation.  Our economy and our industries are grossly overregulated.  There are various estimates of the costs of excessive regulation but one estimate, not untypical, from a former Industry Commissioner put the figure at around 5.5% of GDP.  This is unacceptable.  Pious aspirations for “better regulation” will not do the job.  We need a major campaign of de-regulation – removing unnecessary and failing regulation, analysing costs and benefits, retiring regulations that are failing to deliver and reducing the scope of those which impact too widely.

Thirdly, we need a sense of urgency.  This, again, was something that I felt was missing from the boiler-plate text of your letter, which appeared to have been cut-and-pasted from a thousand similar documents.

Commissioner, in this early stage of your appointment, you have a real opportunity to transform the competitiveness of European industry – not by new or “better” regulation, but by cutting both energy prices and the regulatory burden.  As a prominent American commentator put it, “We don’t need to teach the grass to grow – we just have to get the rocks off the lawn”.

Yours faithfully,



This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Letter to the Commissioner

  1. Ex-expat Colin says:

    Buzek from wiki:

    “In his inaugural address in Strasbourg, Buzek stated that among the greatest challenges faced by the European parliament were the economic crisis, European solidarity, human rights and reform within the Parliament itself.[10] Buzek also stated he would be committed to reform of the European economy, tackling rising unemployment, energy security and climate change, strengthening European solidarity and integration and promoting equal opportunities for women. However, Buzek noted that the Lisbon Treaty would be a prerequisite to any change “(so that the Union can be) well-organised and effective”

    Some of it makes sense…just! But really they are just talking to themselves.

  2. Thomas Fox says:

    Pear Commissioner
    We in the UK are not pleased with the speed of change to anything you are considering .
    Our commercial manufacturing industries who require affordable energy to be competative can not wait two years for you to discuss how to reduce the cost plus the implemention of any such change to take another year after that !
    We therefore wish to withdraw our membership of the EU which we will be completed swiftly as time is money to all industries !
    Tom Fox
    Great Britain

  3. Ian Terry says:

    The second word should be off.

    Our industries have not got the time or the resources to keep on playing these silly games.

    The Uk is £1.5 trillion in debt and the only people who have a cat in hell chance of getting us out of the mess is the manufacturing industries.

    Talk about moving deck chairs on the Titanic.

    You cannot make this up

  4. David says:

    She still will not get it Roger

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s