Daily Debrief March 20th

Turkey: the deal stumbles forward

Despite recent media suggestions that the lollipops offered to Turkey to sweeten the migrant deal had got stuck in the European Council, they seem to have squeaked through.  So Turkey is set to get €6 billion — no small sum — plus visa-free Schengen access in June, and “accelerated accession talks” (though there’s muttering behind hands that accession may be “difficult”).

Nonetheless, Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan seems to have done well.  He gets what are seen in Turkey as huge benefits, and in exchange — what?  No net change in migrant numbers on either side.  Just a few vague promises about tightening the borders (which on the Turkish side seems to consist of soldiers puncturing migrant inflatables with sharp sticks).  Truly, as Dan Hannan has said, Prime Minister Erdogan is a much more effective negotiator with Brussels than David Cameron.

There is the other point that the processing of migrants on Greek islands is likely to present insuperable difficulties.  They’re already planning to send improbable numbers of judges and clerks and administrators and translators to these remote locations.  But each migrant (under laws that never envisaged migration on this scale) is entitled to a personal hearing.  And worse, they can appeal against an adverse decision.  There’ll be a cottage industry advising them how to stretch the process and cause confusion.  This show could run and run until it collapses under the weight of its own absurdity.

The Telegraph headlines “EU Deportation Deal descends into farce as Greeks left in the Dark”:  Local officials complained they had received no extra staff and no instructions how to proceed.  Yet again, the Commission makes decisions in the Ivory Towers of Brussels, and expects them to be implemented as if by magic.  They announced a start date at midnight last night, but apparently gave no thought to the facts on the ground  But with the best will in the world, it’s going to take six months to set up a massive operation like this — and the migrants need to be housed and fed until they can be processed.

There is a fundamental problem with the assumptions of the Geneva Convention.  We are supposed to distinguish between refugees, on the one hand, and other migrants including economic migrants on the other.  The fact is that amongst this vast mass of humanity, it may be possible to identify some refugees, and some economic migrants.  But given the numbers and the way they arrived, often without papers, I suspect the result for the great majority will be “don’t know”.  What are we to do?  Let them all come?  That would be close to Merkel’s disastrous open door policy.  We need new thinking for a new age of migration.  We can no longer stretch rules made decades ago.

My Question Time remarks make the Sunday Express

My warnings about immigration, and the probability that it will rise massively if we remain in the EU, are featured in the Sunday Express.  A pretty fair report.

Government under stress

There have been two major pieces of bad news for the government in the last couple of days.  And remember that for practical purposes the government and the Remain Campaign are one and the same.

First, Osborne’s budget was poorly received.  It was an attempt to get the middle classes on-side with tax breaks.  But the disabled welfare provisions caused great up-set — and not just amongst the disabled.  Even those who take a tough stance on taxes and welfare were shocked.  I was also shocked that Osborne, with a reputation as a “political” Chancellor, should score such an own goal.  He has been humiliated, and his leadership hopes have suffered a major blow.  I believe his Remain Campaign has also suffered a blow.  If the Chancellor can’t get the Budget right, which should we truest him with a major constitutional question — especially when previous Chancellors have been coming forward to take the alternative view?  “Tory Party at war” says the Observer.

Then second, IDS’s resignation.  Say what you will about IDS, he is a man of decency, honesty and integrity.  The subsequent orchestrated attacks on him by government spokesman (including Ros Altmann) were synthetic and demeaning to the government.  The Sunday Times headline: “IDS attack shreds ‘unfit’ Osborne’s dream of Number 10”.  The Telegraph: “Knives out for Osborne in Tory backlash”.  One almost feels sorry for him.  And the Mail: “Outraged Cameron’s four-letter tirade at ‘fraud’ IDS”

Major seems to say that hard trade statistics are “fantasy”

John Major is a voice from the past.  Yet some tell me he is still respected.  I have to admit a measure of guilt here, because more years ago than I can remember I sat on the Huntingdon Conservative Association Selection Committee which selected the young John Major as its candidate.  All I can say in my own defence is that we thought we were selecting a good work-a-day constituency MP — not a future Prime Minister.

But get this quote from today’s Telegraph: “There argument is that the EU needs the UK market more than we need theirs, on the basis that — overall — the EU exports more to the EU than we export to them.  That is disingenuous.  More bluntly, it is fantasy”.

Doesn’t that “overall” suggest that we’re talking a fairly marginal difference?  I’m sure that was his intention.  But the fact is that we buy massively more from them than they buy from us.  After Brexit, we will be the EU’s largest customer, and largest net customer, in the world.  It is Major’s idea that Brussels can ignore that sort of trade imperative that is really disingenuous.  And fantasy.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Daily Debrief March 20th

  1. Pingback: We need new thinking for a new age of migration |

  2. Ex-expat Colin says:

    BBC Non Report Alert

    Migrant Gangs Leave Severed Head On Amsterdam Street

    Don’t want to get used to this and don’t want their local or distant turf wars either!

  3. Shieldsman says:

    What part has Cameron taken in brokering an ineffectual deal with Turkey to ship back the failed asylum seekers (the economic migrants) ?. As he was all for Turkey to be admitted to the EU he probably rolled over and said I will get George to borrow £500million and send it to Brussels for onward transfer.

    Returning to Cameron’s claim to have reformed the EU, it does not appear to have had any effect on the EUSSR, The UN human rights brigade won’t accept Cameron’s Gunboat policy or the shipping back of migrants to Turkey. The other 27 members States will not all agree to accept migrant quotas and the fenced borders will stay shut to counter the anarchic migrant invasion.

    The best of both worlds, the foreword by Cameron is unadulterated bullshit from beginning to end.
    It is riddled with stupid statements. Whatever the British people decide, I will make it work to the best of my abilities.
    He has already rubbished any attempts to make trade agreements, and his negotiating abilities have proven to be nil.

  4. Jane Davies says:

    Roger you say…..
    “Say what you will about IDS, he is a man of decency, honesty and integrity.” I think there are many who would disagree with you. Lying in ones CV is dishonest for starters and there are other examples too many to mention about this mans blatant contempt for the truth.
    I’m glad he has gone as I’m sure many are.


  5. Jane Davies says:

    Ros Altmann who in her past life before becoming pensions minister was a supporter for ending the frozen pension scandal but since her “elevation” has parroted the DWP’s lame excuses for this injustice has made this statement…….you may have already seen it, but if not here it is.

    Personal Statement by Pensions Minister, Ros Altmann

    19 March 2016
    I am extremely shocked by the news of Iain Duncan Smith’s resignation and the way he has behaved.Having worked alongside him as a minister in the Department for Work and Pensions, I have seen that he championed the very package of reforms to disability benefits he now says is the reason he has resigned.I simply cannot understand why he suddenly chose to quit like this when it was clear that Number 10 and the Treasury had told him they were going to pause and rethink these measures. I’m particularly saddened that this really seems to be about the European referendum campaign rather than about DWP policy.
    From a personal perspective, for months I have been silenced by him and what I have said has been strictly controlled. I have had to accept that this is part of being in Government, but am therefore horrified to see him abuse the freedom to take sides the Prime Minister has generously offered to ministers. In particular, I was astonished that he attacked his own government for producing what he called “dodgy dossiers” on the EU situation, which simply sought to set out the facts about this vital issue for our country’s future.
    He seems to want to do maximum damage to the party leadership in order to further his campaign to try to get Britain to leave the EU.
    As far as I could tell, he appeared to spend much of the last few months plotting over Europe and against the leadership of the party and it seemed to me he had been planning to find a reason to resign for a long time.
    I have found him exceptionally difficult to work for. It has been a hugely challenging time for me as he was preventing me from speaking to the public and has often been obstructive to my efforts to resolve important pension policy issues such as on women’s pensions.
    I am looking forward to working with new Secretary of State, Stephen Crabb.

    Pensions Minister, Ros Altman.

    She is firmly in the Remain camp but I await her comments on the frozen pension scandal now she is free to do so….but I’m not holding my breath!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s