Daily Debrief May 8th

Former spy chiefs say Brexit is a security risk

The main headline in the Sunday Times is “Spy Chiefs say quitting EU is a security risk”.  Baron Evans of Weardale, the former director-general of MI5, and Sir John Sawers, the former head of MI6, say Brexit could also lead to “instability on the Continent”, compounding the current “economic difficulties, the migration crisis and a resurgent Russia”.  Both men are at pains to say that they write on their own behalf and were not put up to it by the government.  So I suppose it’s just pure coincidence that their statement comes at the same time as Prime Minister David Cameron makes a pitch to put national security at the heart of the Remain Campaign. This has all the hallmarks of a planned intervention orchestrated by Downing Street.

The view of these gentlemen is in flat contradiction to the recent statement by Sir Richard Dearlove, former head of MI6, who said that leaving the EU would not cause significant damage to UK security, and in material ways – not least in terms of border control – would enhance our security. Sir Richard’s views were echoed by former head of the CIA General Michael Hayden.

This CIA view is significant.  By common consent the UK’s most critical security and intelligence cooperation is with the “Five Eyes” group including the USA, Canada and Australia. Note that the Five Eyes cooperation does not require supranational institutions to make it function: nor should intelligence cooperation in Europe.  European intelligence services will cooperate with the UK because it’s essential to do so for their own security – not because we are, or are not, members of the EU.  In fact closer intelligence integration with the EU could damage the Five Eyes relationship.  The CIA has well known (and well justified) concerns about intelligence leaks from some EU member-states.

Immigration creating “unsustainable pressure” on schools

If the Sunday Times splashes a pro-Remain story, the Sunday Telegraph redresses the balance with a pro-Brexit report. Under the heading “Migration pressure on schools revealed”, it speaks of “huge and unsustainable pressure” on schools from 700,000 children of European migrants.  This includes 25,000 arriving in one year alone.  An influx on this scale would require (says the report) 27 new secondary schools or 100 new primary schools to be built.

Priti Patel says ““These figures show how the EU’s open borders policies, and the uncontrolled immigration that stems from that, is leading to huge and unsustainable pressures on our schools,” adding that it undermines attempts to reduce class sizes.

Of course it’s not simply the numbers.  Many of these children have very limited English language skills, so require much more resource than an English-speaking child.  Meantime the problems in schools are paralleled by similar pressures in housing and hospitals

Terror suspects win human rights appeal

On the same front page, the Telegraph also reports Theresa May’s failure, after ten years of trying, to deport six Algerian terror suspects linked to Osama bin Laden. The Special Immigration Appeals Committee has effectively confirmed their right to remain in the UK, and May is reportedly not planning further appeals.  It is reported that this latest legal action will have cost “a further £1 million”.  It is not clear what the total cost is, but with legal aid, government legal costs, and no doubt welfare payments to the suspects, it will be many millions of pounds.

The complete impotence of the British government to deport criminals and terrorist suspects is surely by itself sufficient reason to vote for Brexit.  Perhaps Baron Evans and Sir John Sawer would like to explain how this latest decision enhances British security.

Energy Levy “to stop blackouts”

Under “capacity markets” arrangements, consumers will pay subsidies of £3 billion to keep old coal, nuclear and gas power stations running through 2017/18 – and to prevent the blackouts which would otherwise be inevitable. This will amount to £38 per household.

The government’s mealy-mouthed justification is that otherwise there would be electricity shortages and price spikes, which could be even more expensive for consumers.

But as the Irishman said, if I wanted to go to Dublin, I wouldn’t start from here.  It was the government’s own green obsessions, its head-banging commitment to expensive and intermittent renewables, and its pusillanimous kow-towing the perverse Brussels energy policies, that got us into this situation to start with.  If we’d stuck to proven, reliable and affordable generation technologies, we wouldn’t be in this hole.  Let’s be clear about this: the problem ultimately comes from Brussels, and as long as we’re in the EU we’re denied a rational energy policy.

UKIP has been warning for several years of the coming capacity crunch.  And it’s not just UKIP: The Institute of Mechanical Engineers foresees an extraordinary 40% shortfall by 2025 if we stick to current policies.  And Sainsbury’s is so worried about power cuts that it is setting up its own, independent generating capacity to keep it going when the lights (and the freezers) go out.

The Germans don’t play cricket (but the migrants do!)

The long shadow of the British Empire reaches to the heart of Germany.  No one in Germany (or at least very few) played cricket.  But now large numbers of migrants in Germany from Pakistan and Afghanistan are taking an interest, and giving a huge boost to the nascent sport in Germany.  I trust I never live to see the day when Germany beats England on the cricket field.  The sound of leather on willow will never be the same.

The City of London is more concerned with global rivals than Brexit

In a thoughtful and thorough analysis  economist Gerard Lyons  of “Economists for Brexit” argues that Brexit should not be a problem for the City of London, and indeed in the medium term may be a life-saver.

His article is well worth reading, but in summary, he argues that London’s main competitors are not Amsterdam, Frankfurt or Paris, but New York, Singapore and Hong Kong.  And the City’s ability to compete globally is at risk from the every-growing mountain of EU financial regulation, not least the financial transaction tax and the bankers’ bonus cap.  Brexit could free the City to compete globally, helping to establish its position for the long term.  If we remain within a declining EU, we may well see the UK’s financial services business decline as well.

Greece: Juncker is whistling in the wind

The Guardian reports that Commission president Jean Claude Juncker says that “Greece has basically achieved its reform goals”, and that therefore talks on debt relief can go ahead.   I suspect that the IMF will want to take a view on that.  The plain fact is that Greece will never repay its debts.  Any further “loans” are not loans at all – they are gifts.  One way or another Greek debt will have to be written off – either inside or outside the €urozone.

Chaos in Rural Farm Payments

Christopher Booker writes a scathing piece about the chaos in the administration of CAP payments to farmers. The British government (he says) has already incurred fines of £642 million to Brussels for its failures, and the figure could reach £1 billion.  The piece is too long to summarise, but worth reading if you have an interest in farming.

TTIP again

The Indy carries a report on “How TTIP will allow the USA to force the EU to lower standards”. In a separate report, the European Commission insists that “TTIP is far from over”, although on the other hand France is hinting it will veto the deal.

Still with the Indy, I was surprised (but pleased) to see that it gave reasonable coverage of UKIP’s remarkable results in Wales.

An amusing neologism

We’ve had Brexit and Grexit.  Now the Sunday Times offers us “Jexit”.  Jeremy Corbyn is reportedly planning to take a week’s holiday just before the EU referendum – perhaps to spare himself the embarrassment of having to argue for a proposition with which he profoundly disagrees.  Pro-EU Labour MPs are said to be furious.  Personally I can’t see it making a lot of difference.







This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

17 Responses to Daily Debrief May 8th

  1. Shieldsman says:

    I read the Guardian article on Greece, but these days I find the comments where allowed, far more interesting if you ignore the silly people.
    Greece is an outstanding example of why the 28 member EU is bound to fall apart. The 19 eurozone member states have such disparagingly different economies the single currency struggles to work. How can any of the proposed new members meet the criteria, after all Greece cheated and look at the state it is in.

  2. David Kendrick says:

    Are not separatists leaving the EU a threat to EU security not visa versa, unless of course they are planning something nasty. Cameron true to form paints Black as White. 2000 years of British security threats are entirely attributable to Europe.

  3. Anyoldiron says:

    TTIP ‘allows’ the EU to “SPEAK” on behalf of the British people-Or Government-to the mighty US of A on ALL matters of TRADE, for all time, if TTIP is accepted, if we remain in the EU. If the EU can do THAT, there is no point in having ANYONE in those TWO Houses of Parliament. What about maintaining our Forces-will the EU make sure THEY have got ALL THEY NEED to keep this-our very own Country SAFE and at all times ready to protect this Island nation of ours?

  4. Ex-expat Colin says:

    Who Buys That Cr*p – Alert

    Jeremy Paxman WITHDRAWS article critical of European Union from next issue of Radio Times ‘after pressure from BBC’


    He could stick it on Bishop Hill or similar. oh…do we get a free Parker (Paxer) pen somewhere?

  5. Oliver K. Manuel says:

    If EU had performed as promised, there would’ve been no campaign to withdraw from the EU.

    It hasn’t and critics are unlikely to be gullible for another meaningless promise for the future.

    • Ex-expat Colin says:

      The prime promise was the EEC and thats what I voted for…no more. What has emerged I know little about as regards promises/intentions. What I see is Governance by those I did not vote for. I resent that.

      EU Central by now should have positively addressed the concerns that they clearly know about now in UK and elsewhere. Not what Cameron arranged with them at various european lunches recently.

      The UK Tory party must know that its days are short and the local elections last week are no indication of any love for them. That was about attempting to control local government so the likes of Labour don’t screw up locally…where they exist they will…bye bye London.

  6. Ex-expat Colin says:

    Meanwhile Canada burns (Boreal Forests). And yes, there is a tiny piece of climate change somewhere there. Apart from that as the Abo’s say..”him white fella can’t manage the land”

    I have fought a couple of forest fires in Germany…bombing range versions. A 500lb practice bomb goes way off target and lights scrub and some trees up. Then it ignites the peat marsh nearby and we then have a place that we can only cook our spuds on. 3 weeks of it and then it rained. Exploding pines were interesting. Man…useless!

  7. MIKE MAUNDER says:

    RE: NATIONAL SECURITY: 1. LEAVE THE E.U. FOR EVER ! 2. Take control of our own Nation, in particular our borders. 3. Use our own choice of who comes to this country. 4. Have faith in OUR OWN FORCES. Police, MI5, MI6, GCHQ and British Armed Forces have all done well so far, and they should be well Thanked for that. 4a. Always realise that retired heads have served well, and a little drink£ on the side is always acceptable ! ! !

  8. MIKE MAUNDER says:

    RE: JEXIT: It might weigh heavy on the mind of Corbyn, that he could be required to join Cameron to tell the people why they should stay in, so a much needed holiday, booked ages ago, (honist ), is sufficient to duck out. Apart from not knowing much about it from a stay in point of view, it would be cringe worthy T.V. Cameron is trying to find a malady that on health grounds, will put him on the sick list, rather than face Boris and Nigel Farage. Both Cameron and Corbyn should resign, in fact this should trigger a General Election !

  9. MIKE MAUNDER says:

    RE: TTIP AGAIN: Only in the E.U. is a bad idea, that has little, to no support from the people, brought back from the grave. But then the Yanks want it ! What price E.U. power ?

  10. Jane Davies says:

    You really couldn’t make this up…..bring it on!

    “Al Gore, announced that his new coalition would find “creative ways” to prosecute fossil fuel companies, individuals, and organizations who disagree with the catastrophic global warming narrative.”

  11. Pingback: Daily Debrief May 9th | Roger Helmer MEP

  12. Pingback: Cameron becomes parody of self |

  13. foxbarn says:

    “*Former spy chiefs say Brexit is a security risk”*

    *Why keep repeating the enemies propaganda as a headline?*

  14. Anyoldiron says:

    Will someone please explain to me, what is the point in having ANYONE in those two Houses of Parliament when all THEY CAN DO is obey the orders of Foreigners? Especially when my generation remember full well, and we were indeed bombed out living near the much used Lancashire Ship Canal in those War years. In those days we fought foreigners to stop them Governing over us. Todays’ Politicians PAY them to Govern us and will do so FOREVER if we do not get out of the EU.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s